A Legacy Rooted In Johnson City
What began with nine worshipers meeting in a small courtroom in downtown Johnson City grew into a thriving congregation serving generations of families throughout the region. From the construction of Bethlehem’s first church building in 1929 to continued growth in catechesis, outreach, and works of mercy, each generation has borne witness to the church’s enduring calling: to proclaim the Gospel of Christ and serve the neighbor.
Highlights Through the Years
1924
First Lutheran worship service held in Johnson City.
1928
Bethlehem Evangelical Lutheran Church officially organized.
1929
Construction begins on the congregation's first church building.
1950
Current church facility dedicated.
2024
Bethlehem celebrates over 100 years of ministry and witness.
The Pastors of Bethlehem Evangelical Lutheran Church
One of the greatest blessings in Bethlehem's history has been the faithful pastors who have guided the congregation through more than ten decades of ministry.
Rev. Claire P. Schulz
1928–1939
Founder and first pastor of Bethlehem Evangelical Lutheran Church. Rev. Schulz led the congregation from its earliest worship gatherings and oversaw the establishment of the church in Johnson City. Under his leadership, the congregation formally organized and began construction of its first church building.
Rev. George Beiderwieden, Jr.
1939–1948
Rev. Beiderwieden guided the congregation through a period of steady growth, increasing worship attendance, Sunday School participation, and church membership during his ministry.
Rev. Elmer G. Neunaber
1949–1951
Rev. Neunaber helped lead the congregation through the construction of Bethlehem's current church facility and parsonage, leaving a lasting mark on the church's physical foundation.
Rev. Paul R. Martens
1952–1957
A former missionary to China, Rev. Martens expanded outreach opportunities and helped launch Bethlehem's kindergarten program, which served local families for many years.
Rev. Roland P. Gabbert
1958–1970
Known for his approachable leadership and commitment to community engagement, Rev. Gabbert faithfully served the congregation for more than a decade during a period of growth and outreach expansion.
Rev. Fred C. Greninger
1971–1977
Rev. Greninger brought a strong commitment to Lutheran doctrine, biblical teaching, and liturgical worship, helping strengthen the congregation's theological foundation.
Dr. Carl J. Stapf
1977–1982
Initially serving as interim pastor before accepting a full-time call, Dr. Stapf helped guide Bethlehem through a season of renewal, encouraging faith, unity, and mission-focused ministry.
Rev. Martin Luther Travis
1982–1991
Rev. Travis oversaw significant facility improvements, including the construction of the Fellowship Hall and additional educational space while maintaining a strong emphasis on Lutheran teaching.
Rev. Robert Mader
1991–1996
Rev. Mader faithfully shepherded the congregation through a challenging season while bringing a deep appreciation for music and worship to church life.
Pastors Don Fichtelman & Willis Ude
1996–1998
These pastors provided important leadership during a period of transition and healing, helping prepare the congregation for future growth and opportunities.
Rev. Steven L. Harmon
1998–2023
Serving for twenty-five years, Rev. Harmon led the congregation with compassion, stability, and a passion for community outreach. His ministry touched countless lives through pastoral care, teaching, and service.
Rev. Vincent Shemwell
2023–Present
Rev. Shemwell continues Bethlehem’s legacy of faithful pastoral service in the Office of the Holy Ministry. With a love for Lutheran theology, history, and liturgy, he serves the congregation through the preaching of the Gospel and administration of the Sacraments, guiding the church into its next century of worship, catechesis, and works of Christian service.
Be Part of the Next Chapter
Whether you are exploring faith for the first time or looking for a church home, we invite you to worship with us and become part of the continuing story of Bethlehem Evangelical Lutheran Church.